Monday, February 11, 2019

#18 Faith – The Reformed


The Reformed

So far, these posts have been running along in a somewhat consecutive manner, earlier to later. In the next series of posts, we will be zeroing in on specific circumstances that have histories all their own: faith/religion, war, coal mining, etc. This will require us to jump backwards a tad on the timeline in order to move forward again as we dip into each of these “special” circumstances. With this post we begin to address the first of these “circumstances”: Faith; and we start with The Reformed



Our progenitor, Philip, was most likely a follower of the German Reformed movement. That is to say, he was a Calvinist. As Christianity developed through the 14th and 15th Centuries, many individuals began to question certain beliefs and doctrines of the Catholic theology. Eventually, leaders, such as John Calvin, and their followers broke with the Roman Catholic Church in the 16th Century. Followers of Calvin and like-believing leaders called themselves “Reformed” Christians. It was the followers of Martin Luther, who also famously broke with the Roman Catholic Church, who gave the Reformed Christians the name “Calvinists”, since John Calvin was the most famous of their leaders. It was their way of differentiating themselves, the Lutherans, from the Reformed.[1],[2]

Martin Luther as depicted in
Mary Drum’s Bible
given to her in 1895
by her husband, Nathan A. Drum.
The bible didn’t include
John Calvin among its biographies
Clearly there were differences between Lutheran and Reformed teachings. However, there were enough similarities that often, once in the new world, strong relationships formed between the Lutheran and Reformed congregations, many often forming “union” churches.[3]

It was most likely Philip’s and Jacob’s connections to the German Reformed community in Pennsylvania that ultimately drew George to the Drums valley. In the Drums Valley he found a strong community of like-believers and like-speakers who took him and his family in as one of their own. He was not in the valley long before he became a leader of the German Reformed community that he found there.

As discussed in an earlier post, (Snarls) he most likely was in in the valley by 1797, therefore, in attendance when, on January 12, 1800, the Lutheran and Reformed congregations met to discuss their respective futures. During this meeting, it was decided these two congregations would collectively build a meeting house that would be used for both worship and school. Prior to this, the congregations were holding their services in private homes.[4]

This image is taken from a 180th Anniversary celebration booklet
published by the St. Johns U.C.C. in 1972.
The caption reads:
“The German log-schoolhouse of St. Johns, PA. in 1808.
Artistic sketch by Kathy Miller.”
The meeting house they built was made of logs and sat looking over the Nescopeck River on land sold to the congregations by Stephen Balliet. The site along the Nescopeck was in a village that was at first called Hughesville, after George Hughes, a prominent citizen and owner of the grist mill[5]. Later the name was changed to St. Johns, named for the congregations of the union church found there, when the establishment of the Post Office exposed the existence elsewhere of a previously established Hughesville Post office. That other Hughesville is now best known as the place where the Lycoming County Fair is held!

 This photo was taken by Edwin Finstermacher prior to 1911. I’ve placed an “X” in the approximate location of the first “log-schoolhouse” church. The star indicates the approximate location of the Reformed Church that was built in 1913. The Lutheran Church was built where the Union Church is in this picture.

According to the St. John’s United Church of Christ (U.C.C), George Drum was a member of the church council and consistory when the building was erected in 1808[6]. The two congregations then asked the Reformed Pastor, Rev. Frederick W. Van der Sloat, to write a constitution and by-laws for them. Van der Sloat’s document in part required the building to only be used for school and worship; no services were to be held after dark; and all services were to be conducted in German. Van der Sloat’s constitution was presented and accepted in 1809. Nineteen men signed the document; among them were John Balliet, Philip Woodring, Michael Beishline, and George Drum.[7], [8]

The church and school building served the congregations well for 20 years. Finally outgrown by 1828, Mr. S. Bennet bought it and moved it to his farm.

The “union” congregation replaced it with a new, larger log building which they built on a lot across the road from the original location. This building was used until 1868 when it, too, was out-grown by the faithful. An addition was built and dedicated in 1873 and the entire structure was remodeled in 1894, this time adding a new organ that cost $800 (approximately $23,000 in present day dollars[9])! 

It is uncertain when this photo was taken however, it is prior to 1911. The photo was taken by Edwin Finstermacher.

However, all was lost in 1911 when the furnace overheated, a fire erupted, and the structure was burned to the ground.[10]

The loss of this building forced the two congregations to examine themselves and their often-difficult relationship with each other. They decided the time had come to separate. Thus, the fourth church was built, or rather, two churches were built to replace the Union Church now in ashes. The Lutheran’s built their new structure on the location of the previous building and the Reformed congregation built their new structure on newly acquired land adjacent to the former location; the two churches being, as one description put it, “less than a stone’s throw away” from each other.

Ella Drum’s uncle, Jacob Santee, recorded a few notes concerning this incident on the cover page of his 1902 Webster’s Dictionary:


“The St. Johns Union Church was destroyed by fire the 4th day of March 1911. 
The last funeral service held in said church was that of Simon Rarich, Feb 11, 1911.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Mar 2 – 1913 – First service held in the new Reformed church St. Johns PA.”

The information in the top right corner added by rubber stamp reads:

After five days return to:
JACOB SANTEE
Drums, PA.





 The St. Johns Lutheran and UCC churches today.

The St. John’s Evangelical Lutheran Church, on the left, was dedicated on February 9, 1913[11] and the St. John’s German Reformed Church, on the right, was dedicated May 12, 1913.[12] In 1962 the name was changed to the St. John's United Church of Christ.
Sorry about the light pole. I tried to move it but it was stuck pretty hard into the ground.




So, the church in St. Johns that owes some of its existence to early leadership received from George Drum has survived more than 225 years, active yet today. As of this writing, I believe there is only one person who is a direct descendant of George, myself, that is still a member. That was not true of all of George’s direct descendants over the years, of course. Naturally, many left the valley to follow careers and lives elsewhere, some living as far away as California, perhaps beyond. However, even of those who remained in the Valley, not all remained members of George’s church.

In our next post we will tour the St. Johns U.C.C. Church and in a following post, look at some of the Reformed/UCC Church activities and events that impacted Drum lives and Drum lives that impacted the St. Johns Reformed/UCC Church! Then in a post after that, we will look at Drums as Methodists. But until then, return on February 25, 2019 for your personal tour of St. John's U.C.C., St. Johns, PA.




[1] www.ucc.org accessed January 31, 2018
[2] Citation for Mary Drum’s Bible:
Williams, Prof. S. W., The Pronouncing Edition of the Holy Bible Containing the Authorized and Revised Versions of the Old and New Testaments, arranged in Parallel Columns, Giving the Correct Pronunciation of Every Proper Name Contained in the Bible. (Phila.: A.J. Holman and Co., LTD, 1895)
[4] 200th Anniversary: 1792-1992 (St. Johns, PA: St. Johns United Church of Christ, 1992)
[5] Bradsby, H.C., ed, History of Luzerne County, Pennsylvania (Chicago: S.B. Nelson & Co., 1893). Chapter XXI (continued): Butler Township. http://www.usgwarchives.net/pa/luzerne/1893hist/ accessed 6/7/2016
[6] 200th Anniversary: 1792-1992
[7] Munsell on Butler Township, 1880, History of Freeland, PA, https://www.andrew.cmu.edu/user/ct0u/munsell_butler.html accessed 8/11/2016
[9] Conversion Calculator: https://www.officialdata.org/
[10] 200th Anniversary: 1792-1992
[11] Two Hundred Years of Progress: Butler Township, 1784-1984 (Drums, PA: The Drums Lions Club, 1984) p 23.
[12] 200th Anniversary: 1792-1992

No comments:

Post a Comment